Research Explains How Innocent People’s Clothing Fibers End Up at Crime Scenes

  • <<
  • >>

 Research Explains How Innocent People’s Clothing Fibers End Up at Crime Scenes

Every time you put on a coat, hug somebody or sit on a sofa you leave behind tiny little fibers from your clothing. You also pick up fibers left behind by other people. This movement of fibers is known as fiber transfer and forensic scientists can use this to solve crimes.

Textile fibers are one of the most important types of evidence in forensic science. And have been pivotal in solving some of the UK’s most notorious crimes– such as the murders of Joanna Yeates, the Ipswich serial killings, the Soham murders and the Coastal Path murders, to name a few.

But establishing textile fiber links is only half the battle for forensic scientists working on criminal cases. What is equally, if not more, important, is to work out how the fibers actually got there in the first place.

To date, it’s largely been assumed that fiber transfer only occurs when two surfaces touch. So, for example, when the front of your jumper touches the shirt of someone you hug, or when the back of your trousers touches the sofa you sit on. But we now know this is not necessarily the case.

A new discovery

Our new research has found a new way that fibers can be transferred: “contactless airborne transfer”. This is when fibers move from one garment to another without contact. So, for example, imagine there are two people in the same room, but they don’t touch each other. It’s possible that fibers from person A’s clothing could transfer through the air, to person B’s clothing (and vice versa).

From the perspective of an investigation, this means that, under certain conditions, fibers found on a person could have been passively transferred rather than through direct involvement in a crime.

In our experiment we used everyday garments - jumpers, long sleeved tops and fleeces – that were fluorescently dyed. This allowed us to track the airborne transfer of their fibers between garments.

One participant wearing a fluorescent garment stood in one corner of an elevator and another wearing a non-fluorescent black top stood in the diagonally opposite corner. Both participants remained in the elevator (without touching each other) for 10 minutes. During this time the elevator operated as normal and non-participants of the study entered and exited as usual.

Following the experiment, the black top of the recipient was photographed using UV-imagery techniques to determine the number of fibers transferred. The results of the study proved that not only can textile fibers actually transfer between garments without physical contact, but they can do so in relatively high numbers.

Often in a criminal case the finding of just a few fibers can be considered significant. So the fact that up to 66 fibers were transferred in a single experiment, was considerably higher than anticipated.

That said, not all garments we tested transferred fibers to the same extent. We found the type of fibers the donor garment was constructed from and its ability to shed those fibers was key in contactless fiber transfer. The type of clothing worn by the recipient also impacted transfer, as did the movement of people and the opening or closing of the elevator doors.

Fiber evidence

When forensic evidence is presented in court, a forensic scientist is responsible for evaluating the significance of that evidence. And our new findings may be particularly relevant for those specific cases where a small number of fibers are found and the circumstances are right for contactless fiber transfer to take place.

For example, imagine two people were in an elevator and one alleges to have been assaulted by the other. If hundreds of the victim’s fibers are found on the suspects clothing, it’s highly unlikely that contactless transfer alone is the reason for the all the fibers. But if only a few fibers are found, contactless transfer is more viable.

And in this way, the results of our study can be used as a baseline in the evaluation of fibers found as part of a case – and will also help to increase the robustness and validity of forensic evidence being presented in court.The Conversation

by Kelly Sheridan, Senior Lecturer in Forensic Science, Northumbria University, Newcastle and Matteo Gallidabino, Senior lecturer in Forensic Science, Northumbria University, Newcastle

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article

Photo: Fiber transfer during the experiment. Author provided